|
What
is momentum investing?
Momentum investing is
the right stock in the right industry at the right price.
Industries that are receiving a great deal of media attention based
on investor driven momentum which then feeds on the media attention until
it most likely burns itself out.
Momentum investing in
any stock, industry, or sector is driven by a combination of factors but
one thing and only one thing creates actual momentum and that is simply a
matter of supply and demand.
Hence the slogan
"buy high, sell higher."
Momentum investing is
not for everyone. It’s risky, requires close attention and ironclad
discipline.
“The investor of
today does not profit from yesterday's growth.” - Warren Buffett
When market orders to
buy any stock outweigh sell orders that stock will rise rapidly. When
whole groups of stocks rise in this fashion they are being subjected to
Momentum Investing. Even in a Bear Market stocks can and do rise rapidly.
Momentum Investing can be a great way to capitalize on this phenomenon for
savvy investors.
Some
examples of momentum investing:
Some recent examples of
momentum investing include:
- Technology
stocks
- Oil
stocks
- Stem
Cell stocks
- Anti-Terrorism
and Anti Bio-warfare stocks
- Defense
stocks
When the momentum or
buzz gets going all the stocks in that industry get buzzed and go up
together. Momentum doesn't generally discriminate based on management,
cash flow or EPS. Companies
must been seen as having products to change the way the world works. There
must be a mystique to the technology - enough so a few gurus can emerge to
explain it.
Traditional ways of
valuating stocks don't work for momentum investing hot stocks.
Current financial results tell you nothing about the company's
potential. Momentum stocks
are emotion. No one can write logically about emotion.
The
lessons of momentum investing:
- Let
the stock run. Don't sell the stock after it goes up 50%. The biggest
mistake everyone makes is selling too early.
- Watch
like a hawk for disappointments. If the company exceeds Wall Street's
estimates (of revenues or losses) by the requisite tiny amount, the
stock will keep soaring. If it misses by even the tiniest amount,
investors will pound the stock into the ground. Get out when the going
gets rough.
- Constantly
search for new momentums.
Momentum winners for
the 90's have included Microsoft (MSFT), Cisco (CSCO), EMC, General
Electric (GE), and more
recently the Internet stocks like Google which have introduced the concept
of top-line momentum, even if earnings are scant or only a distant
prospect.
One problem is that
many who consider themselves momentum investors, do not honor their own
mental stops, and fall in love with the momentum stocks even after they
have lost it. Not only did the investor love the momentum, but they back
filled logic as to why technology would power the market forever.
This is a style that is
not about falling in love, it is about making money.
Momentum
investing Basics:
What do momentum
investors look for? Three things, typically: a strong price chart, rapid
earnings growth and recent positive changes in earnings-growth forecasts.
Generally, momentum types don’t spend much time scrutinizing
fundamentals
Momentum investing is
not a buy-and-hold strategy. Momentum investors typically hold a stock for
a few months. However, they monitor their holdings daily and sometimes
sell much sooner.
The downside of this
investment style occurs when a company breaks its positive trend of
performance or even underachieves market estimates. The decline can be
quick and very painful as “momentum” investors frantically exit the
stock
The result is that,
whenever there is a whiff of bad news, numerous previous buyers scramble
to get out before the barn door shuts. In this type of environment, stocks
become highly illiquid and prices become discontinuous. When the upward
momentum ceases, concentrated selling quickly accelerates, as momentum
investors attempt to be among the first to get out. This not only drives
prices lower but also leads to margin calls, and thus more selling.
As momentum investors
see a rising trend, they all join in, driving prices even higher. It may
seem like a winning strategy, with the promise of high upside and limited
downside -- a bet one apparently cannot lose. But the risk of this
strategy is that, while momentum investors can all pile in at the same
time, they cannot all escape (sell) at the same time unless markets are
both highly liquid (large blocks can be sold quickly and at the same
price) and continuous (prices do not gap sharply downward with no
opportunity to sell).
Relative strength:
This may sound
counterintuitive, but research shows that stocks that have already
outperformed the market over the past 12 months are likely to continue
their winning ways, at least in the short term. Limiting your picks to
strong 12-month performers is crucial to momentum strategies, and relative
strength is the tool of choice for gauging performance
Relative strength, or
RS, measures how a stock has performed compared to the overall market over
a specified timeframe. For example, a 12-month relative strength of 75
means that a stock has outperformed 75% of all stocks, in terms of price
performance, over the past 12 months.
Earnings
momentum:
Now that we’ve
pinpointed stocks with strong price charts, we’ll check the
earnings-momentum side of the equation.
Earnings momentum
starts with strong quarterly year-over-year earnings growth. You could use
the most recent reported quarter’s figure, but I prefer the current
quarter’s forecast growth, because it better reflects current
expectations. In either case, fast growth is the name of the game, and 15%
year-over-year EPS growth is about the minimum to qualify a momentum
stock.
Finally, in the
earnings department, momentum investors look for a positive earnings
surprise in the last reported quarter, meaning that the reported earnings
exceeded the consensus forecasts. This requirement is well-founded because
a variety of studies found that stocks with recent positive surprises
outperform the overall market.
Revenue
and revenue growth:
The parameters above
are sufficient to define momentum stocks in the classic sense. But stocks
meeting those requirements alone will include disasters waiting to happen.
So we’ll add some fundamental requirements to filter out some of these
time bombs.
Few companies can make
money without selling something to somebody. Establishing a minimum annual
sales (revenue) volume weeds out stocks that don’t have solid
businesses. Most publicly traded corporations sell products and/or
services totaling well into the hundreds of millions of dollars annually.
I set the limit at $40 million annually, which equates to $10 million per
quarter.
Avoid stocks trading
below $5.
Very low trading
volumes signal lack of interest, just the opposite of what momentum
investors need. Need minimum trading volume at 20,000 shares, which most
momentum candidates should meet handily.
When
to sell using momentum investing?
Momentum investing was
one of the major fads of the past decade, fueled by the red-hot
performance of technology and dot-com stocks. The prices of these stocks
seemed to rise for no good reason, despite lack of earnings -- or
sometimes even the prospect of earnings. No historical valuation models
could justify the prices achieved by many of these stocks. Unfortunately,
momentum investing, like many other investment strategies, is basically a
strategy that seems to work until it no longer does. In other words, the
strategy may work for some period of time, but by its very nature, it
contains the seeds of its own destruction
Momentum stocks get
hammered when something goes wrong. Consequently, momentum investors must
act quickly at the first sign of trouble.
Note that momentum is a
relatively short effect, the biggest gains were over the next year,
following on from that momentum doesn't seem to affect the stock after a
year, the result is that "momentum" investors frequently need a
very high turnover in their portfolios to take advantage of the effect.
Most momentum funds I know of do indeed have portfolio turnovers of 100%
or more, which only adds to their expenses and takes away from returns.
|